Are AMX M4 mle. 51 and AE Phase I the same tier?

Yes, both are tier 9 heavy tanks in World of Tanks.

AMX M4 mle. 51 vs AE Phase I

Q: Which is better in WoT, AMX M4 mle. 51 or AE Phase I?

Based on a 7-category stat comparison (HP, armor, damage, penetration, DPM, speed, camo), the AMX M4 51 wins 2 categories and the AE Phase I wins 2. Neither has the overall stat advantage.

Both AMX M4 mle. 51 and AE Phase I are tier 9 heavy tanks in World of Tanks. Below is a head-to-head stat comparison across HP, armor, gun performance, mobility, and concealment.

Overall stat advantage: Tied 2-2 across 7 categories.

Need WoT gold or a premium account?

Save up to 40% on premium currency, game time, and bundles via verified key marketplaces.

Compare WoT gold prices →

Side-by-side stats

Stat	AMX M4 mle. 51 France	AE Phase I USA	Winner
HP	1520	1440	AMX M4 51
Hull armor	180	120.7	AMX M4 51
Damage	—	—	Tie
Penetration	—	—	Tie
DPM	—	—	Tie
Speed	33	35	AE Phase I
Camo (still)	6.6%	9.2%	AE Phase I

What the numbers say

The AMX M4 mle. 51 has 80 more HP than the AE Phase I. Hull armor differs by 59.3mm at the front (AMX M4 51 is thicker). 0 Top speed differs by 2 km/h (AE Phase I is faster). Note: the AE Phase I is a premium vehicle and the AMX M4 51 is not — this affects how each is acquired and grinded.

Get AE Phase I as a bundle

AE Phase I is a premium tank. Find current discounts via the official shop or verified resellers.

See AE Phase I in the WG shop →orFind on Kinguin →

FAQ

Which is better in WoT, AMX M4 mle. 51 or AE Phase I?

By raw stats alone, the two tanks are evenly matched. Actual matchup performance depends on map, role, and player skill — but on paper this is the breakdown.

Are AMX M4 51 and AE Phase I the same tier?

Yes, both are tier 9 heavy tanks.

What about other tier 9 heavy tanks?

See the full tier 9 heavy tank tier list for all options at this tier.